Transfer News

Newcastle United could make another Alex Murphy U-turn as muddled thinking continues

Add as preferred source on Google

Newcastle United could make yet another U-turn over Alex Murphy during the January transfer window. 

Murphy is a young defender often seen in the Newcastle United squad, although without ever really being given any minutes. 

The 21-year-old has only ever made four appearances under Eddie Howe, for a total of 26 minutes. 

Which player do you regret selling more – Elliot Anderson or Yankuba Minteh?

Thanks, PSR 😡

Split image showing Elliot Anderson playing for Nottingham Forest and Yankuba Minteh playing for Brighton
Credit: Robin Jones/Jon Hobley/MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images

However, Newcastle stopped Murphy from leaving on loan during the summer transfer window, having already let Matt Targett depart.  

The Irishman has made 15 squads this season and Howe has spoken about Newcastle’s long-term plans for Murphy.

Still, there could be yet another twist in the tale.  

Newcastle United could let Alex Murphy leave on loan

According to The Athletic, Murphy is now one of the players the club would consider sending out on loan during the January transfer window.  

The former Bolton loanee’s immediate future at the club will be based on whether several defensive players return from injury. 

As it stands, Newcastle are facing an injury crisis in that particular department.

Kieran Trippier, Dan Burn, Tino Livramento, Sven Botman and Emil Krafth are all currently injured and their return dates remain unclear.  

Along with Lewis Hall, Murphy is one of few natural options Howe has at left-back.

Would Unai Emery have won a trophy as quickly as Eddie Howe if Newcastle appointed him in 2021 instead?

Don't forget, he was PIF's first choice!

Show your workings in the comments!

A split image showing Unai Emery managing Aston Villa and Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe lifting the Carabao Cup trophy.
Credit: Catherine Ivill – AMA/Sebastian Frej/MB Media via Getty Images

Alex Murphy isn’t the only player Newcastle United have muddled thinking about

Murphy looks in a state of relative limbo right now.

From wanting to leave, to being told he must stay, to never playing, to being praised by Howe when he does play, to now potentially leaving again if a certain set of criteria is met.

The defender could be forgiven for being somewhat confused by the matter.

William Osula warming up before Newcastle United play Tottenham in the Carabao Cup.
Photo by Serena Taylor/Newcastle United via Getty Images

That’s also the case with teammate William Osula

Osula was also stopped from leaving and enjoyed a brief return in the team before rumours started to swirl again.

Osula could leave Newcastle in January after all, along with Murphy. 

It’s perhaps fair to say neither would have benefitted from the extra six months if they do leave. Neither have the club really, aside from having more options on the bench that they rarely used.

Sign up to TalkingPoints for free to join the conversation about all things Newcastle United with Geordie Boot Boys!