Opinion

Newcastle player ratings vs Manchester City: Jacob Murphy the star for beaten Magpies

Add as preferred source on Google

Newcastle United battled hard at the home of the champions elect on Saturday, but Manchester City ultimately emerged 3-1 winners.

Moments of quality from Kevin de Bruyne, Raheem Sterling and Leroy Sane teed up Sergio Aguero – a regular Magpies nemesis – for a perfect hat-trick.

Jacob Murphy netted in an impressive display for Newcastle, though, and here’s how we rated the visiting players…

Karl Darlow – 7

The goalkeeper made a series of good stops and was unfortunate on the penalty, too.

Javier Manquillo – 4

Having failed to get to grips with Sane, the former Sunderland man then conceded a soft penalty in another poor showing.

Isaac Hayden – 6

The nominal midfielder looked comfortable in a back five, although he was one of the victim of Sane’s mazy dribble for the third.

Jamaal Lascelles – 7

This was yet another accomplished display from the captain, who must be in contention for a World Cup place.

Ciaran Clark – 6

Clark made up for a minor error on the opener with a sublime if, perhaps, unintentional assist for Murphy.

Paul Dummett – 7

Having starred in attack against Swansea City, it was the full back’s defensive work that earned the plaudits here.

Jacob Murphy – 7

A first goal in black and white was Murphy’s most telling contribution, but his speed on the counter and quick feet with the ball were similarly impressive.

Jonjo Shelvey – 5

The England international played a couple of incisive passes, but he was flagging badly by the end of a 90-minute shift in which he struggled to match the City midfield.

Mohamed Diame – 7

Diame has developed into one of Newcastle’s key men. He could well have earned a point with a fine run and shot at 2-1.

Christian Atsu – 5

Although there were flashes from the Ghanaian in the first half, his impact paled next to Murphy’s as Kyle Walker dominated the flank.

Joselu – 4

That was the forward’s best moment was an accidental back-heel in the build-up to Murphy’s goal said a lot for his performance.

Ayoze Perez (sub for Atsu) – 6

Drifting in from the left, Perez impressed in Atsu’s place and drew an instinct save from Ederson after Diame wreaked havoc.

DeAndre Yedlin (sub for Manquillo) – 5

The American offered an instant upgrade on Manquillo at both ends of the pitch, but Sane soon tied him up in knots.

Dwight Gayle (sub for Joselu) – 5

The pace and movement of Gayle compared favourably to Joselu, and yet the former still should have done better with a late, late header.