Newcastle United were again held to a 1-1 draw in the Premier League on Sunday as Ciaran Clark’s defensive lapse allowed Crystal Palace to earn a point.

The Magpies had deservedly led through Mo Diame’s strike at half-time, but the struggling Clark foolishly tugged back Christian Benteke to tee up Luka Milovojevic to score a second-half penalty.

Newcastle and Clark fought to preserve a point in the final stages, though, and here is how we rated the visiting players…

Karl Darlow – 7

The goalkeeper combined a string of superb reaction stops with some errors under pressure, while he was unfortunate not to keep out the spot-kick.

DeAndre Yedlin – 5

Despite possessing the requisite athleticism to match Wilfried Zaha, the American’s poor decision-making too often allowed Palace’s star man to roam free.

Jamaal Lascelles – 6

The captain made a couple of minor mistakes early on, but he swept up well when his fellow centre-half was struggling.

Ciaran Clark – 4

Clark’s poor positional play was eventually punished when he needlessly fouled Benteke, but his late block from the same man was vital.

Paul Dummett – 7

Once again, the left-back was one of Newcastle’s top performers, keeping former team-mate Andros Townsend in check.

Matt Ritchie – 6

Having foregone his defensive duties too often this season, Ritchie marked his return to the team with a determined display on the right, helping Yedlin where he could.

Jonjo Shelvey – 6

The England international moved the ball well in the first half, but Palace took complete control after the break.

Mo Diame – 7

Diame was rewarded with a goal from yet another fine display, with the Magpies feeling his absence after a second-half withdrawal.

Kenedy – 7

In just two matches, the Brazilian has already shown exactly what he is able to offer Newcastle. His pace, trickery and final ball will be relied upon in the run-in.

Ayoze Perez – 6

The Spaniard almost put the game beyond Palace in a wonderful 30-second stretch, feeding Kenedy and then drawing a save on the rebound. He faded thereafter, however.

Dwight Gayle – 5

Returning to his former club, Gayle offered very little once again. An early snapshot was as good as it got, with Newcastle missing Joselu’s presence.

Christian Atsu (sub for Kenedy) – 6

Atsu was full of energy after his introduction and almost single-handedly maintained an attacking threat.

Isaac Hayden (sub for Diame) – 6

The midfielder has been a victim of Diame’s fine form, but he acquitted himself well with some key challenges in the final 25 minutes.

Mikel Merino (sub for Perez) – 6

This was not Merino’s finest display in a slightly unfamiliar role, but he at least provided Newcastle with some much-needed presence at the top of the pitch.